Editor’s Note: This opinion piece incorporates feedback from students who requested anonymity due to concerns about potential repercussions.
The Issue with AI in Education
Misuse of AI has become a major concern institutions are addressing (Caltech, MIT). However, some courses have overcompensated with heavier workloads, frequent quizzes, and leaving instructors less time to provide feedback on assignments. Students who avoid the use of AI struggle the most. In just the first few weeks of the fall 2026 term, students are going days on a few hours of sleep, burning out, and missing lectures and coursework, harming their education.
Anonymous Student Feedback
Many courses now take far more time than what they have in the past and their unit allocation, and put an unnecessary psychological pressure on students. Students often have to take 3-4 of these severely underunited courses at once. Consider the following incomplete list of course feedback from a few anonymous students for some anonymous courses:
-
Course 1 (9 units: 3-0-6): Weekly quizzes worth 40% of the grade, each requiring a full proof in 10 minutes, on top of weekly homework taking 10+ hours. With a few other courses built this way, students are reporting only 2-3 hours of sleep daily.
-
Course 2 (12 units: 4-0-8): Each week there are 4-6 hours of lecture, an in-person quiz, 2-3 at-home quizzes, a homework, and practice problems, which can take up to 15-20 hours per week in total and each add an additional task to keep in mind in addition to similar workloads with other courses. The in-person midterm week also has homework.
-
Course 3 (9 units: 3-0-6): 95% of the grade is on the midterm and final, making the process of learning through homework feel worthless while placing an undue power on examinations, which may not be reflective of student capabilities.
Important Matters
-
Sleep loss due to the increased workload harms memory consolidation and health.
-
Relief is hard to get. Campus wellness services, besides CASS, are not able to help grant extensions or exemptions, so students don’t bother raising concerns about their health. The meetings and follow-ups also do take valuable time from students, further contributing to the avoidance of not bringing up health concerns.
-
Students are often afraid to raise concerns about their courses since communicating with an instructor can be intimidating, fear their opinions will not be received well, or don’t have time.
-
The increased workload, in combination with inherent competition that the posted median on the transcript poses has increased stress and reduced collaboration between students.
-
GPA still gates jobs and graduate school. Competitive applicants often have a GPA of 3.8-4.0+. Right now, some serious, intelligent students at Caltech say even 3.0 feels out of reach despite enormous effort, which can completely disqualify them from applying to many roles despite being highly qualified otherwise.
-
Instructors are spending more time creating assessments and less time on feedback. Without a feedback loop between instructors and students or collaboration between students, we are paying nearly $100,000 for lectures and homework, which can simply be found online for free.
-
The current pressure reduced students’ desire to explore exciting, difficult, and/or unfamiliar courses as well as pursuing research opportunities during the academic year.
-
Princeton ended its grade deflation policy after a faculty committee concluded it caused students too much stress.
What Can Help Reduce Stress
-
Readjust workload to align with units listed.
-
Build in flexibility that allows for extensions as needed and add drop sets and quizzes.
-
Reduce the weight of in-person assessments (i.e., quizzes and exams) and increase the weight of homeworks so students are encouraged to learn and complete homework and learn from in-person assessments with lower pressure.
-
Offer optional extra credit opportunities. This can also positively engage students with the material.
-
Count the higher of the midterm and final.
-
Provide guidance on how to use AI tools responsibly and effectively on assignments that allow the use of AI.
-
Give students an anonymous way to raise concerns about courses for faculty to review. Ombuds are not yet strictly enforced, so this feedback avenue is not always possible if courses fail to have ombuds.
-
Major change, but could work if thought out well. Grades can appear as a pass or fail and that’s it. Courses keep the same grading schemes and the threshold for a pass or fail is set by the professor. A Tech article explaining the rational and answering rebuttals is in progress.
Conclusion
We are not asking for trivial courses. We are asking for a balance between rigor, workload, and units, so that students can learn, sleep, stay healthy, be happy, and still have some free time to pursue extracurricular activities that will help shape us into the creative members of society we aspire to be. Many already found Caltech very difficult before, but now it is starting to be impossible. The issue of AI for education needs to be addressed without jeopardizing student health or putting additional stress on students.